Sunday, May 15, 2016

2.08 Detroit Vipers - RB Keith Marshall

In the real world: An ACL tear wiped out Marshall's 2013 and 2014 seasons after a promising start, but he still has elite speed (a 4.31-second 40-yard dash at the Combine opened some eyes, especially given his size of 5'11" and 219 lb.).  The Washington Redskins drafted him in Round 7. Ahead of Marshall right now are Matt Jones, who averaged 3.4 yards a carry last season; and Chris Thompson, a small speedster with a history of injuries who is better off as the passing-down/change-of-pace back.
In the TUFF world: I might have gone with Malcolm Mitchell or Braxton Miller, except that I need running back depth more than wide receiver depth. I love Marshall's size-speed combo and potential job situation. And he was one of the last RBs worth taking at this point in Round 2.

2.09 San Diego Slewage - QB Christian Hackenberg

In the real world: Here's the story: Promising quarterback prospect plays well under one college coach and is heralded as a future NFL franchise quarterback, but is inconsistent, holds on to the ball for too long and takes too many sacks, and ends up falling to the halfway point of Round 2 of the NFL Draft. Sound familiar? It should, especially to anyone who drafted Jimmy Clausen six years ago.

Hackenberg looks the part with his size and his arm, but as Sigmund Bloom says, "His accuracy comes and goes in an unsettling way." Nolan Nawrocki: "Prone to emotional sideline outbursts and bad on-field body language and could learn to channel his frustration more effectively." After a great 2013 season under Bill O'Brien, Hackenberg didn't fare as well under Nick Franklin over the past two seasons. In fairness to him, he suffered behind a patchwork offensive line that included two converted defensive tackles. Pocket awareness and accuracy are question marks.  The Jets drafted him in Round 2; their only other QBs are Geno Smith and Bryce Petty (and that's assuming they don't re-sign their best QB from last year, free agent Ryan Fitzpatrick).
In the TUFF world: The Slewage already have Joe Flacco and Andy Dalton, two steady if unspectacular QBs, but that doesn't stop Todd Hansen from stockpiling younger signal-callers. Flacco and Dalton should buy plenty of time to find out if Hackenberg can be the answer for the Jets at quarterback. San Diego also has two second-year QBs as well: they drafted Brett Hundley in Round 3 last year and later signed Garrett Grayson as a free agent.

2.10 Baltimore Brown Clowns - WR Malcolm Mitchell

In the real world: "Mitchell will never project as a #1, which limits his fantasy ceiling, but his athleticism, route running, hands, ball skills, and toughness will be very useful as a #2, and in a good pass offense, he could be very productive. He is just coming into his own after a 2013 ACL tear, on a celebration in the end zone." - Sigmund Bloom in his pre-draft 100. Mitchell landed in a terrific job situation in New England, whose top two wideouts right now are Julian Edelman and Danny Amendola, both of whom are 30 and smaller in size.
In the TUFF world: Baltimore needed help at wide receiver. Andre Johnson is pretty much done (note: the Brown Clowns have released him since making this pick), Larry Fitzgerald is entering his 13th NFL season, and 2013 first-rounder Cordarrelle Patterson has been a huge disappointment. Mitchell could be just what the doctor ordered.

2.11 Dallas Golden Tornadoes - PK Roberto Aguayo

In the real world: Aguayo could be best PK prospect to come out in several years (if not the best since Sebastian Janikowski, then certainly the best since Mason Crosby). The Tampa Bay Buccaneers traded up in Round 2 to get him and solve their kicking problems once and for all. Last year, veteran Connor Barth was just 6-for-11 from 40 yards or more (he was cut earlier this month). The Bucs had tried to go with a younger and cheaper option in Kyle Brindza, but he fizzled out quickly.
In the TUFF world: Aguayo should be an upgrade at kicker over Greg Zuerlein, who was stuck with a stagnant offense and only made 20/30 FGs despite supposedly having a really strong leg; and Kai Forbath, whose job situation is unsettled at the moment (he is set to battle Josh Scobee for the Saints' placekicker job). That's not why he gets the question mark here. The reasons for the question mark are:
  • DeAndre Washington (potential handcuff to Latavius Murray) was still on the board at this point;
  • Braxton Miller (insurance for Dallas' second-round pick from last year, Jaelen Strong) was also still on the board; and
  • As far as solidifying the kicking situation was concerned, Scobee is in the free agent heap.
Dallas risked losing out on both players by passing on them here, whereas had they passed on Aguayo, the only way they would have missed out on him at their next pick (2.16) would have been if the Cleveland Steamers and/or Tennessee Taz Devils--teams in need of backup kickers--had moved ahead of that spot.

(Editor's note 5/19/16: Today, four days after I published this Draft Wrapup, the Saints cut Scobee and signed Barth.  Barth is not a free agent in TUFF; the Steamers held on to him.)

2.12 Green Bay Ground Hogs - WR Mike Thomas

In the real world: Sigmund Bloom is really big on this prospect from Southern Mississippi: "The big play game in the air and ability to summon up something extra when the play calls for it gives me a lot of confidence in Thomas' ability to get even better after coming from modest beginnings." Works hard, but questions abound about how well he can separate on the NFL level. He lands with the Los Angeles Rams, who drafted him in Round 6; their top wideouts are Tavon Austin and Kenny Britt, but every other spot on the WR corps is up for grabs. Not to be confused with the New Orleans Saints' 2nd-round pick or the former Jacksonville Jaguar.
In the TUFF world: Green Bay traded up with Pittsburgh from 2.14 to get this pick. They had to cough up their third-rounder next year to make it happen. It seems like a bit of a steep price considering that Braxton Miller was still on the board, there was no clear-cut best wide receiver after Miller, it was just two lousy spots, and next year's draft promises to be much richer with talent than this year's. Maybe how Matt Waldman reviewed his performance had something to do with it.

2.13 Arizona Outlaws - TE Austin Hooper

In the real world: For the Atlanta Falcons, Hooper could be the long-overdue replacement for Tony Gonzalez (who retired after 2013). His NFL.com draft profile compared him to another Stanford product, Coby Fleener, but also added that Hooper could put on 8-10 pounds of muscle to his frame without losing any speed, and thus be a more well-rounded tight end than Fleener has been.
In the TUFF world: Getting a new starting tight end was one of the Outlaws' priorities--Owen Daniels and Scott Chandler were unsigned free agents when this Draft Wrapup was published (and in fact, the Outlaws released Chandler), and Mychal Rivera will likely lose playing time to second-year man Clive Walford on the Raiders.

2.14 Pittsburgh BIG PAPAS - RB DeAndre Washington

In the real world: The Raiders, who have Latavius Murray, Roy Helu and Taiwan Jones, wanted to bring in a back to compete with Murray for carries, but ultimately did not take one until picking Washington in Round 5. He's small but strong and tough.  It's hard to read into his college stats because he played at Texas Tech (and therefore got the bulk of his carries against soft Big 12 defenses--you didn't think I'd go through a Draft Wrapup without mentioning the Big 12, did you?).
In the TUFF world: I seriously considered Washington at 2.08 before deciding on Keith Marshall.  This pick is good at this point--neither a steal nor a reach--and Pittsburgh did well to take him here because, in addition to Chris Johnson and Darren McFadden getting up in age--both are about to enter their ninth NFL season--there are plenty of ifs and maybes (like "What if Karlos Williams and Mike Gillislee remain stuck behind LeSean McCoy?" or "Maybe T.J. Yeldon will never be a lead back in the NFL").

2.15 Denver Devils - WR Braxton Miller

In the real world: Converted QB Miller turned heads with the athleticism he showed as a wide receiver. The Houston Texans took him in Round 3. Although they already have DeAndre Hopkins, Round 1 pick Will Fuller, Cecil Shorts, and Jaelen Strong (taken in Round 3 of last year's draft), there are a couple things that make Miller's long-term job situation more appealing:
  • Shorts, however, becomes a free agent next year (and he may even be cut for salary cap reasons this year).
  • Strong had conditioning issues as a rookie and was arrested for marijuana possession in February.
In the TUFF world: At this point, I wondered how anyone can be having a better draft than Denver has had. They moved up to get WR Laquon Treadwell without giving up a future first-rounder, put themselves in the perfect position to get QB Carson Wentz, selected the best tight end available in the draft in Hunter Henry, and then there's this awesome value. Miller could be the #3 wideout in Houston as soon as next year, especially if Shorts leaves and Strong turns out to be a bust. Heck, if Will Fuller doesn't cure his dropsies, a hard-working Miller could be #2 to Hopkins.

2.16 Dallas Golden Tornadoes - WR Tajae Sharpe

In the real world: Sharpe, the most productive received in the history of the University of Massachusetts football program, was drafted by the Tennessee Titans in Round 5. Lean at 6'2", 195 lb. Plusses: Footwork, route-running. Minuses: Hand size, leaping ability (the latter could hurt him when matched up vs. bigger cornerbacks). He was one of the standouts during the week of the East-West Shrine Game.
In the TUFF world: All those other options I was talking about at 2.11? They're all gone. You know that analogy I mentioned a few years ago where the early part of the NFL Draft is like ordering off a menu, and the later part is more like a buffet?  There's a big drop-off in talent after Braxton Miller, the last "menu" player this year.  Welcome to the buffet line.

3.01 Indianapolis Hoosier Daddy's - RB Wendell Smallwood

In the real world: The Philadelphia Eagles, after trading away RB DeMarco Murray to Tennessee, didn't have much beyond injury-prone Ryan Mathews and 33-year-old change-of-pace back Darren Sproles. Smallwood, the only back the Eagles drafted, grew up watching as an Eagles fan in Wilmington, Delaware, and aspires to be like Westbrook. He's fast (4.41 40) and can catch passes and pass-protect as well as run, but as a runner, doesn't offer much in the way of shiftiness or acceleration.
In the TUFF world: Getting a handcuff at a critical position in Round 3 without having to trade up or trade away future picks? I'm sure Indy will take that anytime. I certainly would.

3.02 Tennessee Taz Devils - RB Kelvin Taylor

In the real world: Taylor didn't do much to stand out in his one season as Florida's starting running back, and Rotoworld says he'll be a situational back, not a threat to Carlos Hyde's job. He does have better ball security than most of the other rookie RBs (he never fumbled once in 510 career offensive touches).  The other backs in front of him in San Francisco are Shaun Draughn and Mike Davis, who haven't done much to stand out themselves.
In the TUFF world: The Taz Devils needed depth at running back, but had to pass on it in each of the previous two rounds in favor of better players at WR and QB. They may be ticked off at Detroit's selection of Keith Marshall at 2.08 (he would have been a great handcuff for Matt Jones and Chris Thompson).

3.03 Minnesota Fighting Saints - RB Daniel Lasco

In the real world: Todd McShay: "Lasco's lower-body explosiveness and top-end speed (4.46 40) give him a lot of upside as a RB." The Saints drafted him even though they already have four running backs (Mark Ingram, C.J. Spiller, Tim Hightower, Travaris Cadet). Lasco demonstrated his athleticism at the Combine and had a really good season in 2014. In between, though, he suffered through hip and ankle injuries.
In the TUFF world: After taking two WRs earlier on, the Fighting Saints turned to the one area on their roster that needed the most help--running back. The Saints, under Sean Payton, have made good use of their RBs over the years (starting with Reggie Bush and Deuce McAllister, and later on, Darren Sproles). And from a fantasy standpoint, you never know--Lasco could beat out Cadet for a roster spot, then be one injury away from being a key contributor.

3.04 Indianapolis Hoosier Daddy's - WR Rashard Higgins

In the real world: The Cleveland Browns took Higgins in Round 5, and in my estimation, he's the best of the receivers they drafted on the third and final day of the NFL Draft.  He's quicker than he showed at the Combine--he put on weight because he was on the skinny side in college--and showed how productive he could be in 2014 (before his QB, Garrett Grayson, left for the NFL, and his coach, Jim McElwain, left for Florida).
In the TUFF world: Indy had an interesting choice to make here. There's no denying that Higgins is a great prospect--I would have considered him at 3.08 as a handcuff for Corey Coleman--but at the same time, I wonder if Indy considered taking QB Connor Cook to handcuff to Derek Carr (my guess is, they did, but passed).

3.05 New Orleans Chocolate City - QB Dak Prescott

In the real world: A dual-threat QB who has been called a less-polished Donovan McNabb and a far more NFL-ready version of Tim Tebow, Prescott was the Senior Bowl MVP.  But he was arrested on March 12 for DUI—just hours after hosting a camp for more than 200 children. Drafted by Cowboys in Round 4 as they search for a backup for (and possible long-term successor to) Tony Romo. Dallas went 1-11 without Romo last year, and at present, their only other backup is Lions castoff Kellen Moore.
In the TUFF world: The Chocolate City got its Romo handcuff.  That's the pick I would have made in their situation.

3.06 Tennessee Taz Devils - RB Josh Ferguson

In the real world: Todd McShay: "Ferguson has similar quickness to (UCLA's Paul) Perkins. He would be higher if he didn't dance in the backfield so much. He'll try to make air miss when there's no need. But he flashes really special agility and quickness. Plus, Ferguson is a 4.48 guy, so he's fast enough to rip off chunk yards when he gets a seam." Cause for concern: he had six fumbles in 145 carries in 2014. Still, Ferguson lands in a terrific job situation in Indy; their top two backs are 32-year-old Frank Gore and journeyman Robert Turbin. Neither is a scatback, meaning Ferguson could play a Darren Sproles- or Dion Lewis-type role in Indy.
In the TUFF world: I really like this pick precisely because of the job situation. I would have taken him if he had fallen to 3.08.

3.07 Tampa Bay Meat Goats - RB Tyler Ervin

In the real world: Todd McShay: "Ervin is an intriguing prospect. He can play in the slot, and he's really good at making guys miss in the screen game. With an explosive first step, he'll also be an asset in the return game." Rotoworld's Evan Silva labels Ervin a scatback/return specialist. He's a little bigger than the Titans' Dexter McCluster, but may be used in a similar fashion.
In the TUFF world: Well, he is a running back, and you can never have too much depth in a 16-team league. It'll be interesting to see how the Houston Texans, under Bill O'Brien, will use him.

3.08 Detroit Vipers - WR Charone Peake

In the real world: Peake was a highly sought-after recruit coming out of high school, but didn't get to produce much while playing behind Sammy Watkins, Martavis Bryant and DeAndre Hopkins at Clemson. Hands, ball skills, durability (a torn ACL caused him to miss 2013; complications from that injury caused him to miss most of 2014 as well) are why Scouts, Inc. initially graded him a 37, but Sigmund Bloom thinks highly of him and NFL.com graded him 5.8. He's got a nice size-speed combo (6'3" with a 4.45 40) to go with NFL-caliber build and physicality, and that adds up to a good deal of upside. Now with the New York Jets, Peake already has a fair shot at the #3 wide receiver job (Devin Smith is still recovering from a torn ACL).
In the TUFF world: The upside and the grades from Bloom and NFL.com were reasons I took Peake even though he fell all the way to Round 7. Reason #3: It so happens I have Smith (my second-round pick last year).

3.09 Dallas Golden Tornadoes - TE Tyler Higbee

In the real world: Higbee comes into the pros with more than enough upside to be the Rams' starting tight end--their current starter Lance Kendricks, who has had more than 32 receptions only once in five seasons--but he comes with a couple red flags. He missed six games last season with a knee injury. Three weeks before the NFL Draft, he was charged with second-degree assault, second-degree evading police and public intoxication. Higbee pled not guilty on May 5, claiming he was acting in self-defense.
In the TUFF world: San Diego originally had this pick, but traded it to Detroit last year, and Detroit traded it to Dallas for a 2017 3rd-rounder. The Golden Tornadoes were looking for another tight end--their only other tight end is Clive Walford, drafted just last year--and missed out on the top two rookie TEs this year (Hunter Henry and Austin Hooper). Anyway, injuries and off-field issues are not as big a deal in this round as they would be in Round 1.

3.10 Baltimore Brown Clowns - WR Demarcus Robinson

In the real world: Robinson's athleticism makes him dangerous on the field. However, his off-field baggage (4 suspensions in 3 years; he has admitted to failing three drug tests) make him dangerous off the field. Rotoworld's Evan Silva calls him and fellow KC draftee Tyreek Hill "gadget-type receivers," presumably meaning they're only good for gadget plays. With that said, until the Chiefs settle the #2 and #3 wide receiver spots, this is a decent job situation.
In the TUFF world: Here's another low-risk, potentially high reward pick.

3.11 Carolina Convicts - RB Tre Madden

In the real world: The Seattle Seahawks signed Madden, the grandson of former Rams RB Lawrence McCutcheon, as an undrafted free agent out of USC. He's big but not fast. Not creative, but will take what's blocked. Has a history of injuries (knee, hamstring).
In the TUFF world: Now there are four teams with a vested interest in the Seahawks' RB situation: Minnesota (Thomas Rawls), Baltimore (C.J. Prosise), New Orleans (Alex Collins) and now Carolina with Madden. (The Cleveland Steamers have Christine Michael, too, but he's only on a one-year contract after bouncing around with a few different teams last year.)

3.12 Pittsburgh BIG PAPAS - QB Connor Cook

In the real world: Andrew Healy of ESPN.com noted that Cook had the benefit of playing with the most NFL-caliber teammates of any prospect in this year's class, including All-America left tackle Jack Conklin. Unlike his predecessor at Michigan State, Kirk Cousins, Cook was never voted a team captain. He only completed 56.1% of his passes despite not facing a lot of particularly strong defenses (note: it was at 58.1%--consistent with his previous two seasons--before he injured his shoulder last November against Maryland). His accuracy on short and mid-range passes is particularly maddening--he's been guilty of "putting too much pepper" on his short passes; in short, for all his experience, putting the right "touch" on his passes is still a concept that eludes him.
In the TUFF world: "A backup for Andrew Luck" was on Pittsburgh's shopping list entering this draft. They had passed up QBs Jared Goff and Carson Wentz at 1.12, although that was understandable because they needed to handcuff RB Jay Ajayi (which is why they took RB Kenyan Drake). However, Cook isn't going to be Luck's backup, at least not anytime soon.

3.13 Arizona Outlaws - QB Cody Kessler

In the real world: The Cleveland Browns were expected to take a quarterback to either supplant reclamation project Robert Griffin III, or at least compete with him. Kessler isn't expected to do either, and in fact profiles as a backup (adequate arm strength, takes what the opposing defense gives him).
In the TUFF world: The Outlaws picked Griffin fourth overall in 2012 with the hope that he would be a big upgrade over Carson Palmer. Fast forward to 2016, and Griffin is the backup to a now-36-year-old Palmer. Still, this is a good pick for Arizona just because it shores up their depth at quarterback for this season.  Passing up QBs Jared Goff and Carson Wentz at 1.13 is still a gamble, but at least now the gamble's not so big.

3.14 Houston Tethered Swimmers - TE Seth DeValve

In the real world: What were the Cleveland Browns thinking?!? Here they were, making this big deal about analytics by hiring ex-baseball exec Joey DePodesta as their new GM, and in Round 4, they drafted DeValve, who is too slow to be a wide receiver (4.68 40) and doesn't yet have the bulk or strength to be a tight end. Frank Cooney's NFLDraftScout.com profile ranked him 47th in this year's TE class, and NFL.com's draft profile projected him to be an undrafted free agent.
In the TUFF world: This pick is OK for the Tethered Swimmers because they're drafting him as insurance for their most productive TE last season, Gary Barnidge. If Barnidge were to get hurt, DeValve would stand to benefit. With that said, if I were in Jeff Rathburn's shoes, I would have drafted WR Chris Moore (as insurance for last year's first-round pick, Breshad Perriman).

3.15 Green Bay Ground Hogs - QB Cardale Jones

In the real world: Jones went from third-string QB to hero for Ohio State late in 2014, leading them to the national title in the first-ever College Football Playoff. He has some work to do regarding footwork (he never took a snap under center and thus needs to work on three- and five-step drops) and accuracy. However, he's got great size and a cannon for an arm, which gives him the same upside as JaMarcus Russell, without any of Russell's downside. The Bills will not pick up E.J. Manuel's fifth year option, NFL Media Insider Ian Rapoport reported. There are conflicting reports about what will happen with Tyrod Taylor, who is also set to become a free agent. NFL.com says extending Taylor's contract is on hiatus, while Buffalo's GM has said that the Bills want to extend him.
In the TUFF world: Green Bay seemed like they were seriously screwed when the Philadelphia Eagles drafted Carson Wentz, but this is an ingenious pick. Why? Because after the draft, Green Bay and Denver (the team that drafted Wentz) could theoretically talk turkey about a trade in which one team would have the Buffalo Bills' quarterbacks, and the other team would have the Philadelphia Eagles' quarterbacks, thus solidifying QB depth for both teams.

3.16 Carolina Convicts - WR Keyarris Garrett

In the real world: The Carolina Panthers signed Garrett as an undrafted free agent out of Tulsa. He broke his leg in 2013, and had surgery to have a titanium rod inserted, but due to an infection, he had to have that surgery all over again. He has a good combination of size and speed 6'3", 220 lb., 4.53 40). He was 20th on Sigmund Bloom's Pre-Draft top 100 list, and he was mentioned a few times as one of the draft's better small-school prospects.
In the TUFF world: Garrett landed on my draft board for two reasons: It's not often that an undrafted free agent wide receiver gets drafted in the TUFF Draft (DaRick Rogers in 2013 was a notable exception), but such is the case when the talent pool is shallow as this year's is.